Sample comparison · local demo
Three roofing estimates organized around what's named, what's not specified, and what's worth clarifying. A lower total is not automatically a better fit.
| Scope item | Harbor Roofing Co. $18,450 | Northline Exteriors $16,980 | Pine & Peak Roofing $19,775 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Materials | Architectural shingle named | Not specified | Architectural shingle named |
| Permit | Included | Not specified | Homeowner listed |
| Warranty | 10-year workmanship | Not specified | 5-year workmanship |
| Cleanup & disposal | Included + magnet sweep | Not specified | Included |
| Change orders | Written approval required | Approval language not specified | Written approval referenced |
| Project timeline | 2–3 working days | About one week | 3–5 working days |
| Quote Clarity Score | 84 | 61 | 76 |
Scores reflect completeness, transparency, and possible risk—not contractor quality, value, or legal compliance.
Harbor Roofing Co.
Named shingles, line-item labor and clear payment stages.
Ask this contractor
Could you share the unit price and approval process for any decking repairs found after tear-off?
Northline Exteriors
Lower total, with several scope details not specified.
Ask this contractor
Before I compare this estimate, can you confirm the shingle product, permit responsibility, workmanship warranty, and any disposal charges?
Pine & Peak Roofing
Detailed material list with a few ownership and timing gaps.
Ask this contractor
Can you clarify who will manage the permit, and confirm when final payment is due relative to the final walkthrough?
How to use this
Use the comparison to request missing details, confirm scope, and decide what may require further review. QuoteCheck does not tell you which contractor to hire.
Start your own project